by Luca Fumagalli
Among the various historical essays written by Hilaire Belloc – many of which are fascinating psychological portraits of the most important figures in English history – those devoted to the tumultuous 17th century are among the finest. In particular, in his Charles I, published in 1933 and reprinted in 2025 by Mysterium Press, the Anglo-French apologist recounts the end of the English monarchy as it had existed for centuries, caused by the rebellion of the wealthier classes. A power struggle that had little concern with the majority of the population. The beheading of Charles I in 1649 marked the expiration of a king regarded as the protector of his subjects against threats to their freedom, whether from within or outside the country. After the end of the civil war, England was thus destined to become precisely the kind of aristocracy and plutocracy against which Belloc himself would fight, both as a journalist and as a Member of Parliament.
Signs of a crisis within the monarchy were already evident towards the end of Elizabeth’s reign. Although the Queen had succeeded in the difficult task of maintaining the prestige of the Crown, it was in financial decline due to rising prices and the increasing costs of public administration. Above all, almost all the new and substantial endowments that the monarchy was supposed to have gained from the confiscation of monasteries, hospitals and colleges under Henry VIII had passed mainly into the hands of the squires, both great and small. These men, who were members of Parliament, gradually became increasingly influential, supported by the lawyers who until recently had served the sovereigns faithfully. What happened also explains the growing hatred of Catholicism following the death of Mary Tudor: the aim was, first and foremost, to ensure that the wealthier classes retained the economic gains of the Reformation.
In 1625, after his father’s death, Charles became king and Parliament began plotting to usurp his power, taking advantage of his youth and inexperience. The only hopes for the new ruler lay in the army and the support of the people, but unfortunately he lacked both. Meanwhile, the unstable foreign policy of Lord Buckingham and his military failures also contributed to a worsening of an already compromised situation. Thus it happened that Parliament, convened with unusual frequency by a perennially money-seeking sovereign, ultimately succeeded in limiting his powers.

However, after Buckingham’s assassination, Charles resolved to rule England by imposing his will, without yielding, for the purpose of giving the country administrative and religious unity. This effort was in the true spirit of the time, for it meant enhancement of the nation. In doing this, he could count on the support of men loyal to him such as Treasurer Weston, Bishop Laud, Noy the lawyer, and the great administrator Thomas Wentworth. Between the violent ending of the confused Parliament of 1629 and the calling of the Short Parliament and the Long Parliament in 1640 they worked to make all the British Dominons one state, strengthening the fleet, giving a solid and shared doctrine to the national Church, and attempting to completely absorb Ireland. After all, it looked as if Charles might actually succeed, but the rebellion of the Scottish Calvinists definitively swept away all hope.
At this point, to face the immediate danger of an invasion, the king was forced to convene a new Parliament which took advantage of the situation to start a full-blown civil war. After the initial successes of troops loyal to the king, Parliament created the so-called New Model Army led by Oliver Cromwell, who severely defeated Charles at Naseby. The sovereign was eventually captured and, after a clumsy attempt to ally himself with the Scots to regain power, was tried and sentenced to death.
Moreover, the outcome of the civil war was already written before the first clashes began. While on the moral level the two sides were equal, on the material level the differences were enormous: not only did Parliament control the ports, the fleet and London, by far the most important city in the kingdom, but it could also count on regular revenues of money. Charles had only one opportunity for success. If he had managed to win a decisive action at the start of operations and, once won, advance directly on the capital, with a proposal ready for compromise, he could have re-established himself. But that didn’t happen and he lost his head on the scaffold.
Ultimately, Belloc’s Charles I proves to be an indispensable essay for understanding the roots of economic modernity. Through the tragic fate of the Stuart ruler, the author does not simply describe a political and religious struggle, nor does he simply weave the praises of a monarch too often unfairly ridiculed; but, most significantly, he describes the birth act of modern capitalism. Beyond possible reservations about the author’s ideological bias, the essay stands out for the usual lucidity of Bellocian prose and the strength of its arguments. Belloc does not seek the neutrality of academic historiography, but signs a work of declared intellectual militancy, capable of drawing forth consolidated narratives. Again, his conclusion is a warning that still resonates today: the death of Charles I was not the triumph of popular freedom, but the beginning of the uncontested rule of great patrimonies over Western society.
Hilaire Belloc, Charles I, Mysterium Press 2025, 306 pages, £18.99.
Purchase link: https://www.mysteriumpress.com/shop/p/hilaire-belloc-charles-i
Follow Radio Spada:
- Publishing House: https://www.edizioniradiospada.com;
- Telegram: https://t.me/Radiospada;
- Gloria.tv: https://gloria.tv/Radio%20Spada;
- Instagram: https://instagram.com/radiospada;
- Twitter: https://twitter.com/RadioSpada;
- YouTube: https://youtube.com/user/radiospada;
- Facebook: https://facebook.com/radiospadasocial.
